Lindsey Bakewell and her dog, Wellington, left New York to open a bakery in Beacon Harbor, where Lindsey has acquired a boyfriend, hunky former Navy Seal Rory Campbell, and a high-maintenance best friend, beautiful Englishwoman Kennedy Kapoor, whose former beau, police officer Tuck McAllister, is still madly in love with her even after having been relegated to friend status. On a visit to town, Kennedy’s grandmother, mother, and sister are staying in Lindsey’s lighthouse home, keeping her busier than a bee. Plus, she’s making an appearance on a British cooking show, Nibbles From Across the Pond, that’s about to film in Beacon Harbor. Kennedy’s mother is thrilled to meet the show’s host, Vivi Lemonberry, even though her past is a bit checkered. The filming gets off to an unfortunate start when the ever-friendly Wellington tries to befriend Vivi, who’s terrified of dogs. Then Vivi makes a pass at Rory, seemingly takes pictures of Lindsey’s recipes while teaching her to make a Bakewell Tart, and gets slapped in the face by rival cookbook author Gretta Gardiner. Vivi doesn’t show up for a planned tea party, and when Lindsey goes for a scuba diving lesson with Rory the next day, she’s horrified to find Vivi dead in the water, her hands tied with a dog leash and a tennis ball in her mouth. Apparently, someone’s framing Lindsey, but once the police, Lindsey, and her friends dig into Vivi’s background, they turn up oodles of motives. Now, they just have to figure out which is the right one.